Yelp Now Has Court Permission to Manipulate Ratings for Money

Yelp Now Has Court Permission to Manipulate Ratings for Money

Yelp Now Has Court Permission to Manipulate Ratings for Money

Do you remember all of those recent and not-so-recent accusations that the popular business listing website, Yelp, manipulates its ratings for money? Well, the accusations might not be that far from the truth. For years, a number of business owners have been claiming that Yelp uses the promise of good ratings, as well as the threat of bad ratings, to sell advertising space. Basically, if a small business decides to buy a big chunk of advertising space from Yelp, they're more likely to get a five star review. Likewise, a business that decides not to buy advertising space will probably be stuck with a much shittier rating.

That taco place around the corner that didn't buy ad space? Yea, it might not be there for too much longer.

taco no

As you may have gathered, this alleged practice not only pisses off small businesses, but it causes them pretty significant difficulty in a business environment that's becoming more and more tech driven. Because of this, a group of business owners decided to band together and do something about it by proposing a class-action damage suit against the company.

The proposal was dismissed in a 3-0 decision last Tuesday.

Shit

On September 2nd, the Ninth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco ruled that the practice - while not yet proven to be in use by the company - would not be breaking any laws. According to federal appeals court Judge Marsha Berzon, "as Yelp has the right to charge for legitimate advertising services, the (alleged) threat of economic harm ... is, at most, hard bargaining," and not extortion or unfair business practices. 

That's pretty heavy. That means that, while Yelp spokespeople continue to claim that their review selection process is automated and doesn't judge based on ad-buyer status, they would be well within their rights if they were to decide to start. And, considering how often small businesses rely on favorable reviews, Yelp would essentially be forcing these business owners to buy advertising space lest they find themselves in a less-than-ideal situation.

 Completely Fucked

Share this article

Comments

Content Stream

You need to get on this. Montreal has a new artist on the scene, and he goes by the name Clyde Forest . This dude got on our radar as soon as we laid eyes and ears on his craft through his instagram profile and his debut single. Immersed in a place that lies between contemporary urban with a rock...
You already know about Jaymie Silk . If you don't, then brush up on your knowledge as he's been on our radar for quite some time now as the new rising star producer and DJ, particularly known in the Montreal vogue scene. He just dropped his latest EP titled Watch Me just in time before his...
Donzelle is a beautiful mix of questionable metaphor rap, deadpan dancers, unrefined costume changes and heavy dirty bass. You might remember her name from back around the neon/electro-rap days, you might just not, and that's okay. She's back with a brand new single and visuals to accompany her...
Young self taught producer, Kultur keeps on climbing the ladder and asserting himself since the release of two EPs and several singles that caught the attention of the interwebs. After a year spent putting flesh on the bones of his universe, he comes back with "OCEAN" , his new single featuring...
iamhill is a force to be reckoned with. This self-made emerging artist is talented in a raw, underground type of way. She took it upon herself to produce, write, record, and perform "Give It a Rest" - A catchy single with few words that will get stuck with you as you play it on repeat. It was...
EVERY WEEK. We feature the best underground tracks & remixes, and most of them are up for free download. We prioritize Canadian producers and acts but it is not exclusive. Every Sunday, we'll round-up all of our favourite remixes and tracks we've received through submissions and lay them out...
Nothing better than some fire beats to warm you up in this damned cold weather. MORRIS just recently dropped a 6-track project titled GOOMBAWAVE on soundcloud. A collection of beats based on those species of sentient mushrooms from Nintendo's Mario franchise. You don't need to listen to it in any...
Birthday Boy & Trish release new single titled “Chance To Go Far” off their upcoming EP titled Joseph , out on January 19th via Bastard Jazz . We recently featured the single “Magic” off the same EP, which they had released to close out 2017 with a bang. Further emphasizing the project 90s R...
This emerging artist has been on our radar for quite some time now. Langston Francis is a young visionary who grew up in the centre of Kensington Market and was heavily influenced by the Toronto music scene. His first single "FCKD IT UP" has been making the rounds of the interweb, especially for...
Watch the video above. Life is a journey of twists and turns, leading us to moments of both true bliss and great despair. In her new video "Prime Time" , Singer-songwriter Liana takes us on an emotional adventure throughout the breathtaking landscapes of Peru – a visual odyssey that reflects a...
"Confessions..." is an on-going column where we invite readers to submit their most outrageous personal stories anonymously for everyone to read. These stories are real, and usually come from people who lead double lives. Due to the nature of the subject matter, all identities are kept anonymous to...
We took Parsons' graduate Panisa Busayanont 's Life Cycle collection to New York City's Central Park. Shoes by Aldo . Photographed by Sami Claire . Follow us on Instagram for your fashion fix.